ReviewReviewReviewReviewReviewRhapsody Digital Music ServiceFeb 17, '05 5:51 PM
for everyone
Category:Other
You ever have one of those purchases that you're utterly and completely satisfied with? I signed up for the Rhpasody streaming music service last weekend and so far this definitely falls into that category. I've been addicted to it right from the moment I signed up!

Unlike other pay-per-download services, Rhapsody is primarily a subscription service where you can play any song they have for either $9.95/month or $24.95/quarter. I say primarily because they also have radio stations and you can burn songs to a CD for $.79/track. I might try the radio stations at some point, but have no interest in buying tracks. Mostly because it seems like the quality isn't too good if you burn to CD and then rip back to MP3.

The big selling point here is that notionally you can listen to any song any time you want. Reality is that they don't have every song, but they do have over 800,000. I've definitely run into some things they don't have, but not enough to diminish my enjoyment of the service.

I'm a big music fan, but my annual purchases of CDs have dropped way off in recent years. I just don't feel like buying CDs unless I really know I'm going to like it. Except for the rare occasion that I get to park myself in front of a listening station at Virgin records, my evaluation of a new disc is pretty much limited to 30-second clips on Amazon. You just can't get a feel for a CD that way.

I absolutely love being able to really listen to new music now. I can try out anything I want, whenever I want. It's really like being a kid in a candy store! For a music lover, it's really an amazing feeling. Plus, there's all of those albums (album?! what's that?) that you'd like to listen to once in a blue moon, but would never consider buying. Now you can listen to them whenever you want. They even have children's music for Lyla.

Obviously, the downside to this is that you can't take the music with you. In other words, you can't download songs onto an MP3 player. I'm not concerned about that, as my iPod is filled with 3,000+ tracks from my CD collection. I am curious, though, as to how this will affect my buying of CDs. I suspect that it will cause it to drop even further (or even eliminate all purchases) because I don't commute to work and only need music on the go for when I go down to the gym. My current collection should suffice there. I suspect that the only way I would actually buy a CD now is if I really, really loved it and wanted to have it on my iPod and accessible wherever I go.

The application itself is well designed. You can use keyword searches to find music, or you can browse by genre. For each artist they have a short overview, most popular tracks, a sampler of songs, similar artists, in addition to the artist's albums, singles and compilations that contain the artist. You can add albums and individual songs to your library for easy access in the future. The library could probably be a little more robust, along the lines of what you'd find in iTunes or MusicMatch, but it does the trick. You can also create and save playlists.

I'm listening to the music on a PC with a wireless connection and the quality is great. I've only had the connection dropout once.

There's a 7-day free trial and I would really recommend that any music lovers out there give it a shot. Props to Gersh for turning me on to this!

tracy wrote on Feb 17, '05
Lyla likes to listen to the Chipmunks and The Wiggles.
michaelg wrote on Feb 17, '05, edited on Feb 17, '05
dave said
Props to Gersh for turning me on to this!
No problem Dave.

I'm still trying to figure out the best way to get Rhapsody on my living room stereo. I'm probably going to pull the trigger on D-Link's Media Server despite some mediocre reviews. I'll let you know how that works out.
lmychajluk wrote on Feb 18, '05, edited on Feb 18, '05
Nice post. I've been thinking of looking into a music service again, but I want to be able to:

1) If I pay for a downloaded song, it better be in a decent bitrate. I'd prefer 196kbps at a minimum.

2) Be able to do anything I want with that file (copy it to any of my PC's, copy to MP3 palyer, copy to or stream to my PDA, burn it 10x, etc...).

3) No proprietary software / player, or file format.

Here's a tip, though - if you find a music service with a decent quality that will allow you to burn a CD, there's nothing stopping you from ripping that CD back without any DRM.
dave wrote on Feb 18, '05
Here's what CNET has to say about the download part of their service...

When you buy tracks, they're recorded directly to CD by a burning app that's built into the Rhapsody software. The CDs are recorded as audio discs, and files are inconveniently named Track 1, Track 2, and so on. The only way to transfer Rhapsody tracks onto your hard drive or MP3 player is by extracting the tracks from the CD with an audio ripper, such as Musicmatch Jukebox. The upside is that once you've ripped the tracks from the CD, you're free to use them however you like. In our tests, the audio quality of ripped Rhapsody tracks was acceptable. Although Rhapsody says the naming snag will be remedied in the near future, this direct-to-CD system will continue to be inelegant until then. It's worth noting that about 80 percent of Rhapsody's streaming catalog is also available for download.
lmychajluk wrote on Feb 18, '05
I was just browsing thier Artist list. They had about a hundred artists named "G - something", but yet, no Gordon Lightfoot. !?!?!? If I can't pick up the odd single from some obscure artists, maybe this service isn't for me...
dave wrote on Feb 18, '05
Maybe that list isn't up to date. I did a search within the service and they've got about 10 of his albums, but when you click on each one it seems as though they've actually only got a subset of the tracks for most of them. Not sure why that is. Maybe a licensing issue.
lmychajluk wrote on Feb 18, '05
I've just been checking out MSN's Music service... They've got some pretty good terms, as far as I'm concerned:

-
- Downloads from MSN Music are encoded as 160kbps WMA files for the best in audio fidelity. (I'm cool w/ WMA, though some aren't. I think WMP10 will re-encode to MP3 on the fly if you're Xfering to an MP3 Player that doesn't support WMA.)
- No monthly subscription: Most individual tracks cost 99 cents and most albums cost $9.99 -- and the music is yours to keep, burn to CDs or take it with you on a portable audio player.
- Generous rights*: MSN Music allows you to play your music on up to five Windows PCs, burn playlists to CD up to seven times, and transfer to an unlimited number of portable audio devices. (You can also control which 5 PCs are 'authorized' to play your songs, which was a concern of mine since I'm always buying and rebuilding PCs.)
-

Seems like they have 1/2 to 1 Million songs, which seems comparable to the other services, along w/ short streamed previews for each track. That's the subscription-free music download service. They also have a radio service you may want to check out, and it's only $5/mo, and only if you subscribe to the 'Premium' service (more channels, higher quality streams, etc...). Check it out.

http://music.msn.com
dave wrote on May 9, '05, edited on May 9, '05
Rhapsody recently introduced a "To Go" service so that you can transfer tracks to a portable MP3 player. If I actually ever left my house, I would definitely replace my iPod with a player that worked with this service.

I honestly can't ever see buying a CD again, and I think this type of service (Napster also has a similar one) will quickly replace pay-per-song as the dominant model.

A new version of the Rhapsody application was introduced along with the launch of this new service. The new app has a music library similar to what you'd find in iTunes, MusicMatch, etc., and you can include any MP3s you have. Your library is essentially a mix of tracks you actually own (i.e., MP3s) and those that you can play via your subscription. And now you can move any of those tracks to your MP3 player, although it must be one that works with their service.

This service costs $15 per month (compared to the $8 I pay currently), which I would glady pay to listen to whatever I want, whenever I want, and now whereever. I guess that's not completely true, but it's pretty close now.

Even without the To Go option, I would still strongly recommend Rhapsody. Using it over the past few months, I've been able to discover lots of new music and listen to lots of things I never would have risked buying.
Add a Comment
How would you rate this thing? (optional)
   
© 2008 Multiply, Inc.    About · Blog · Terms · Privacy · Corp Info · Contact Us · Help